Imagine welcoming your newborn into the world, only to face accusations of drug use based on a faulty test.
That nightmare became a reality for Melissa Robinson, a Huntsville librarian, who tested positive for cocaine at the hospital—even though she’s never touched the drug.
Melissa’s ordeal began when routine drug testing during childbirth flagged her for cocaine. Shocked and confused, Melissa and her doctors suspected a mistake.
However, Alabama’s Department of Human Resources (DHR) launched an investigation.
Despite a follow-up test proving her innocence, the case remained open until further scrutiny was conducted, including a home inspection and additional testing of her husband.
Sadly, Melissa’s story isn’t unique. Hospitals routinely test women during childbirth, and these tests can result in false positives—as high as 50%, according to investigative journalist Shoshana Walter of The Marshall Project.
Items as ordinary as poppyseed bagels, heartburn medication, or prescribed blood pressure drugs can cause erroneous results, placing families in the crosshairs of a system meant to protect them.
There’s no national requirement for hospitals to confirm these initial drug tests before reporting them to Child Protective Services.
This lack of oversight has left families, like Melissa’s, entangled in a complex and invasive process they never should have faced.
In Alabama, infants who test positive for drugs at birth are automatically reported as neglected or abused.
While there’s no specific requirement to test mothers, the lack of mandatory confirmation before reporting creates a situation where innocent families can be swept into a system that is difficult to escape.
The question remains: How many more families are being caught in this flawed process, and what can be done to prevent it?
You May Also Like: States and Hospitals Shift Toward Less Punitive Drug Testing for Pregnant Women and Newborns